Google has rejected a request from the UK government to remove a video message recorded by Russell Brand in prison and posted on YouTube, in a refusal that has prompted ministers to warn that new legislation may be needed.
The request was made through the Prison Service, and the Ministry of Justice is investigating how the video came to be recorded and posted, the Guardian reported. A Google spokesperson said its teams were investigating and that content suspected of breaching its policies would be removed.
The refusal drew a sharp political response. Former minister Jess Phillips said a new Online Safety Act is likely needed, on the grounds that Ofcom’s existing codes are voluntary. Housing minister Matthew Pennycook told Sky the video was “quite disturbing” and asked viewers to imagine being one of the victims, and a minister said he hoped Google would reach the same decision Meta had in a comparable case.
Why it matters
The row is a live test of the limits of Britain’s online safety regime: a government can ask, a platform can refuse, and the regulator’s codes — as Phillips put it — do not compel. Whether Parliament now moves to give those requests legal force will say much about where the balance between platform discretion and state power settles next.




0 comments